|
|
Anyone have any feedback on this roller from Baliegh? The brochure rates it for 1 1/2" sched. 40 pipe and 2" X 2" X .125 wall sq. tube. I have a considerable amount of this material to roll into large radii and am wondering if this unit will be sufficient or do I need to bite the bullet for a powered roller. There are 30, 15' sections of sq. tube to roll to a 100' radius and probably 70 sections of 1 1/2" sched 40, 16' long to roll to radii 40'- 50'. Obviously, the manual unit has the drawbacks of more physical work and reduced or more demanding attention for repeatability, but I would greatly appreciate feedback from anyone with experience with the tool. I am especially concerned with having to adjut the material to keep it in plane so it rolls flat. My timeframe for ordering to start production is fast approaching and your experience will help determine purchase.
Reply:Anybody? Needed to bump this so it didn't gel lost too quickly. Feedback would be great gentleman.
Reply:If I had that volume and I were planing on doing it (opposed to sending it out), Then some power roller would be in the plan. Otherwise you could video the operation and post it as a new work form--kettle bell, Mace, hula hoop, resistance belt, manual ring roller.With the manual roller you will probably need to do multiple passes per part, since it could be very difficult to start rolling if you crank it to the final depth of the first pass. Though a 100 nor 50 foot radii don't seem that tight. Ironically. for one off stuff I use my Am Bender over my ring roller because it is easier to tweek. By the way they do sell large radius forming dies for those bender too. If I could find the proper dies then I would choose over the manual roller.I wouldn't think you will have any issue with "out of plane" issues fpr those radii. I would be more concerned with those that don't come out perfect and need tweeking especially unbending. A power ring roller might open up new avenues for income too.
Reply:Shane from Baileigh hangs at Pirate 4x4 as well as many large scale (and smaller scale) users. They should be able to point you the right direction. I didn't look to see your locale but they have show rooms with working demos of virtually everything they sell. Give Sahne a call, he's a good guy.Enough stuff to build and repair wrinkled up race cars or bring a classic back to life...
Reply:Thanks for the replies guys. It pretty much just comes down to the money. Could do the manual unit with the needed dies for about $1700.00. The powered unit for 2" square with a set of 1 1/2" dies is gonna run about 9 grand. So I guess I was just hoping to get away with being a skinflint, although I really would like the powered roller. Have talked with Shane several times, yeah, good guy and helpfull. Indicated the work could be done with a manual but it was going to present a lot more problems, which I was measuring against cost. Figured if anyone had worked with the manual unit with good, reliable, consistent results and could reccomend it I'd go with it. Positive feedback in comparison with manufacturers sales quotas was what I was looking for. Well it will be a nice tax write off and look good in the shop. |
|